I keep her picture on my phone. Her smile—wide—open to the sun. Her eyes are like coal with a hint of soft light.
If I had an altar, I’d place her beside smooth stones and magnolia branches. But the world is digital now. Marigolds and myrrh are out of place. And for a nomad like me, far too much to carry.
**
Last year, I read about a sermon written and preached entirely by ChatGPT. The avatar, a bearded black man, encouraged Bavarian churchgoers to trust in Jesus. I conjure images of old ladies in feather-brimmed hats eagerly lined up to talk to the preacher avatar after service: No good husbands. Cake recipes. The Building Fund.
I type “create an altar” into ChatGPT. If I’m going to have this thing, it might as well be of use. It spews a perfect list of altar items with speed and a smirk, like the know-it-all in your class who reads ahead and answers questions the teacher has yet to ask.
I want AI, like the preacher avatar, to become the altar. But specificity is paramount, and I think in puff clouds and underwater sea anemones. I focus and will myself to get more precise.
“Can you hold an altar?” I type into the empty field. I watch intently as the cursor moves across the screen, “As an AI, I’m not physical and thus cannot physically hold or maintain an altar. However, I can certainly guide you through the process of creating and maintaining the altar. If you have any specific questions or need assistance with altar-related topics, feel free to ask!”
**
I’ve learned that there is an unspoken hierarchy of grief: an expected timeframe for visible pain. Loss of a parent or a child at the top. Spouse, next. Siblings, then grandparents. Extended family members, friends …and so on. I look at the grief flowchart to see where this most recent loss lands, but there is no box for this. For Echo, a stranger, that could have been a friend.
**
I am working at a nonprofit when I have my first top-tier loss. I stumble into my manager’s office with my skull blown off.
“I’m so sorry. I didn’t want to ask you this, but HR is requesting documentation,” she says.
“You mean that she died? ” I furrow my brow.
“Yes. It’s just procedural. I’m so sorry…”
I realize quickly that even a first-tier loss will not save me from the violence of verification.
At home, I dig through my bottom drawer and produce a crumbled program titled “Homegoing.” I highlight my name in the long list of people left behind. The next day, I place the obituary on my manager’s desk with a sticky note, drawing a line from my mother to me. Proof of impact.
**
“Quiet as it’s kept…”
Every summer, I read The Bluest Eye: In the bathtub, on the subway, strolling down the street with the smell of the hot city pooling beneath my dress. I’ve signed up for a class studying the work of the prolific truth-teller, Toni Morrison. I remember seeing her at a 92nd Street Y event—how she towered above us in a dimension beyond comprehension. I thought, “A woman with no edges.”
Morrison wove the story of Pecola Breedlove, a little Black girl discarded by the world. A story of her eventual madness. Her life: a procession of unforgivable tragedies.
I knew Pecola. We all did.
When the semester comes around, we dissect Morrison’s literary tropes and devices: Pecola’s unraveling, her wish for blue eyes—and the little girls around her desperately trying to hold her up. And finally, we arrive at Pecola’s violent rape.
Walking into class that morning, I feel a lump in my throat. Professor G. writes a single prompt in chalk on the board: Pecola’s father’s behavior was an act of…
Immediately, my mind begins to fill in the blank: violence, degradation, horror…
But from the edge of the table, I hear Chris, the boy in rimless eyeglasses, yell, “The consequence of a racist society.” His utterance punctures the air. “Morrison has turned him into a one-dimensional character, just like she always does to Black men.”
My throat collapses. The seminar devolves into a litany of justifications. The class is seated in a circle, but I am no longer in the circle. Like Pecola, I’ve slipped away, crushed by the weight of our intellectual exercises.
I follow Pecola down the hall. I make it my duty to witness her. To listen to her, even in her madness. I stroke her hair as she imagines her blue eyes in the mirror. Looking over her shoulder, I see her blue eyes, too. And I watch the world respond to this beauty with gentleness, holding her, a bruised rose bud severed from the stem.
“Don’t go. Don’t leave me. Will you come back if I get them? Get what? The bluest eyes. Will you come back then? Of course, I will. I’m just going away for a little while. You promise? Sure. I’ll be back. Right before your very eyes.”
**
I move to California after graduate school. I am enamored with the Redwoods. I sneak into the forest on weekends to bathe in off-grid hot springs and collect pine cones. I take pictures of tree roots splayed across the earth. They look like veins: the lining of lungs and epithelial cells.
When I get home, I lay each pinecone on my window seal and wait for the baby ones to open. They reach out, expand, and breathe. Like fractals, they are perfect copies of each other, repeating a simple pattern.
**
The first time I see Echo, I love her all at once. I am with Ina. Ina is the perfect kind of California cool. A professor who smokes pot. Ethically non-monogamous with a healthy 501k.
We fan out into a small theater with wooden chairs, and I listen as the room comes alive. Ina grabs my hand, but an invisible cord pulls me back. In this place, she feels unfamiliar. I am ever aware of the sea of Black and Brown faces. I hadn’t expected to see us against this backdrop. I am unprepared.
I don’t quite know why I am here yet. For once, I followed a recommendation from a work colleague.
“Go see this play!” Susan yells at me.
The lights dim, and a petite, sinewy frame slivers onto the stage. It is Echo. She is dressed in all black, and her hair is pulled back into a high bun. Alone under a single spotlight, she holds the room.
“Becky, what should I wear? The jeans with the pink belt?
And when I open the door, do I kiss him with my mouth closed or open? Do I lean in? And what if he pulls back?”
Echo hangs up the phone and looks out into the crowd. She is in a whirl of excitement–and so are we. She is fresh out of Dartmouth and living in the heart of NYC. Ryan is a white hipster from Poughkeepsie. They met through a Craigslist ad. And he loves her.
Quiet as it’s kept…
Ryan is Echo’s first sexual experience. He makes her feel beautiful and safe. Echo is stunning, her onyx skin glistening under the light, but we live in the upside-down world—a hall of mirrors—of Black girl not-enoughs.
Somewhere in the night, the crowd disappears, and I am pulled into a liminal space. An undeniable force has propelled me here. Echo and I sit face to face. Echo holds up a mirror to our lives, and I step in.
The slow strangulation of poverty. Yes, I know. Collect prison calls. I know. Eating from the edges of the table of plenty. I know. Climbing life with no safety net. I know. Dark nights, always waiting at the door–threatening to swallow you whole. I know. Little Black female bodies–unguarded–collapsed against the vultures and the thieves in the night. Yes, I know. I know.
“Not my child!” Echo screams in a thick southern drawl.
Suddenly, I am released back into the crowd. Echo’s girl self is in a sterile medical examination room. Her mother, crying in the corner, howls, “Not my child!” Echo lies on the exam table, her small legs dangling precariously over the edge. Rubber gloves on baby limbs.
“Hush!” I scream under my breath, but Echo continues. I want her to stop. We vowed never to speak of such things.
“We’ve survived!” I want to yell. We command white spaces. White imaginations. We stitched our mouths shut. But here is the thing about magic: For something to live, something must die. In the dark theater, I pray for the confrontation to end.
At home, I look in the mirror. I touch the wound. If I remove the mask, I think I will never be put back together again.
**
I see Echo’s show three times that year, and then when she returns the following summer. I bring my friends and lovers, offering a translation for the unabated sadness in my eyes.
“She feels like me,” I say.
The last time I see Echo, she invites the audience onto the stage for a meet-and-greet. I patiently await my turn. I want to hug her, sit with her on the ground, and compare notes when I get to her. “Thank you for existing,” I say. We lock eyes, and she flashes that wide-brimmed smile.
**
It’s March 2021, and I wake up to an email titled, “Echo Needs a Kidney.” She is 36 years old.
At work, I can’t focus. “She can’t die,” I say over and over. “Of all the people in the world, she can’t die.” And almost unconsciously, I begin making a list of people who can. So many.
**
I don’t know how or why I decide to give her my kidney. It was an all-consuming impulse, like lungs gasping for air.
“Dorothy lived with one kidney, so can I,” I assure my friends over my last boozy brunch.
I remember poking my grandmother’s stomach. “Is it this side, Grandma?” I’d ask. “Stop, child. I’m tryin’ to work,” she would smile, slapping my tiny hand away.
After an initial call with Echo’s medical guardian, I find that Echo and I are the same blood type and only a few years apart. I think maybe God saved me for this.
Over the following days, I talk to the living kidney donation nurse manager. “She must be special,” she says. “So many people have come forward to help someone they barely know.”
I think of the story of Tinker Bell and her light dimming as she begins to die. I imagine each of us with every clap, willing Echo back to life.
I rush to the lab for a bevy of blood tests. And then I wait. I watch copious YouTube kidney donation videos; learn about the different incision scars; start planning my time off from work; and make a detailed surgery aftercare plan. I wait and wait.
I finally call the nurse again. I can hear the trepidation in her voice when I reach her.
“I’m sorry. The antigens in your blood are incompatible with Echo’s. I’m so sorry. You are not a match.”
**
That year, our paths diverge like two roads in a wood. I resign from my job and move abroad. I am ever so aware of the tenuousness and tenderness of each sunrise. I want to be free.
I follow Echo’s kidney donation journey peripherally, but never too closely. I am living in Mexico when Echo organizes a Zoom meeting for an update. With some distance, I am finally ready to see her again.
I anxiously log on to the call early, and Echo appears on the screen. The once luminous woman with a wide-brimmed smile is now a shell of herself. I can feel her weariness spiraling through time.
She tells us about doctors who ignore her pain and vindictive nurses who hurt her. They’ve postponed her surgery, suspending her in space. I want to tie my heart to hers.
**
I am walking on a cobblestone street in Chiapas, Mexico, when I feel a tug on my skirt. I look down to see a little girl with two shiny pigtails, holding a tray of colorful earrings. In broken Spanish, I ask her how much. I take the bright red tassel earrings for Echo and yell, “Gracias!” as the little girl disappears into the crowd.
I slide the earrings into my purse, reminding myself to send them to Echo’s post office box once I find a new home. But I never get the chance.
Two days after my birthday, and two months before her rescheduled surgery, Echo dies. Under a September new moon, Echo releases her swan song.
I cry in my bed for days.
**
There is a Portuguese word, Saudade: “ A vague and constant desire for something that does not and probably cannot exist.” There is no direct equivalent in English. I rail against the futility of the English language. So brutal. So reductive. No space.
I finally have a word to wrap around this experience. I lost something. Somebody that I used to know. The feelings of absence, for a life that could have been, are strung together in perpetuity.
**
I return to the United States a few months after Echo’s death. In my grief, I find my way into therapy. I am ready to share the story: the honest story about where I have come from and what I have carried.
I am ready to tell the truth about what I sacrificed to survive.
My therapist, a 50-year-old woman with brown skin and the softest eyes, holds my little girl self, Echo, and the pain of all the dead women in my family, to the light. And we speak.
Like a 3D puzzle, I can feel the pieces of myself whirling in time. All of the fragments folding back into me.
After a year and a half of traveling the world in search of liberation, I realize this is freedom–the courage to stand in the full, exquisite, and brutal truth of your life. Echo died free. And she freed me, too.
**
At the end of the article about the Bavarian Avatar preacher, the author concedes the limitations of AI. “A real pastor is in the congregation. She lives with them. She buries the people. She knows them from the beginning,” he writes.
Next to a basket of pinecones and red tassel earrings, I place a picture of Echo, Pecola, and a photo of my 7-year-old self bent over a pool on a hot summer day, ready to jump in.
I imagine the three of us with flowers in our hair.
Laughing.
Holding hands.
And walking each other into the blazing sun.
************
Are you a Black woman writer? We’re looking for short stories and personal essays to feature on our digital and print platforms. Click HERE to find out how to submit.